Well this post goes into the abyss of the virtual world that does not care too much about what I write or read.. but that has never bothered me too much. So what have I been reading..
1. Angela's Ashes: Brilliant, inspiring and warmed the cockles of my heart. Will review soon.
2. In Cold Blood: Capote is a genius, this book completely different from the rest he wrote but the method to that book and how it all comes together is just amazing
3. Shantaram: There was a reason this book was languishing in my book shelf gathering dust for 3 years, mostly because it sucks! It is self indulgent, incredulous and just plain boring. Another reason I will not pick up books written on India to charm the stupid westerner.
Oh did I add did all this while I was on a trip to Ladakh, magical magical place.
Currently reading nothing, started Dangling Man by Saul Bellow yesterday. But currently I am kind of dangling in there my self. Not sure how will life unfold... not sure what I want to do...is the angst worth it or should I just enjoy the ride?
I know deep deep questions, I mean I am pretty philosophical myself... mostly my thoughts are around what's the new excuse not to exercise.But this doing nothing is growing on me dangerously.
Sunday, August 8, 2010
Friday, July 2, 2010
The Unbearable Lightness of Being
This has easily been one of the most powerful books I have read in a long long time. It blew me over. Reading the book was reminiscent of the heady feeling of drunkenness that overwhelms you on discovering new love, on listening to Pt. Jasraj live in an auditorium for the first time, on having the first furtive kiss, on seeing the sun dance on the water to make way for the moon on the banks of the Ganga for the first time. The book was almost cathartic in how it forced me to slow down for a second to absorb the enormity of what I had just read.
Milan Kundera is a genius and “The Unbearable Lightness of Being” is perhaps his most recognized work. I have read “The Art of a Novel” and “Identity” by him earlier, had my aha moments with both of them but now they just pale in comparison.
The book like many of Milan Kundera’s work does not follow a time or a narrative continuum rather it follows an emotion continuum. Various incidents, people and places figure in the book as and when they are indispensable pieces of the jigsaw puzzle of the emotion that is being explored. But nothing is incongruous or disparate, all characters, all subplots and all subtexts come together harmoniously to create this wonderful story. Something completely distinctive (that perhaps makes this book a masterpiece) about Milan Kundera’s style of writing is that he defines characters not by how they look or what they wear, not even by what they say but by what they think and why they think and how they think. Finally the backdrop of the book is the chequered and tattered life of East European communist nations, but in this great book political theory plays second fiddle to the people and their emotions that get affected by politics, politics almost becomes personal.
Enough said, will complete the review with some of the gems that stayed back with me from the book. I don’t think you need a context to appreciate them but if you do then don’t forget to pick up the book.
“For there is nothing heavier than compassion “
“If mother was sacrifice personified then a daughter was Guilt with no possibility of redress”
“Of course I am happy.. The only kind of woman who can say that is very… limited. .. Not limited, very anachronistic.”
“But when the strong were too weak to hurt the weak, the weak have to be strong enough to leave.”
“Love was not an extension of public life but its antithesis.”
“Music was the negation of sentences, music was the anti word.”
“The first betrayal is irreparable. It calls forth a chain reaction of further betrayals, each of which takes us farther and farther away from our first betrayal.”
“Because love means renouncing strength”
“What fell to her lot was not the burden but the unbearable light ness of being.”
“Indeed, the only truly serious questions are the ones that even a child can formulate.”
“It is a tragicomic fact that our proper upbringing has become an ally of the secret police. We do not know how to lie”
“Human time does not run in a circle, it runs ahead in a straight line. That is why man cannot be happy, happiness is the longing for repetition”
Milan Kundera is a genius and “The Unbearable Lightness of Being” is perhaps his most recognized work. I have read “The Art of a Novel” and “Identity” by him earlier, had my aha moments with both of them but now they just pale in comparison.
The book like many of Milan Kundera’s work does not follow a time or a narrative continuum rather it follows an emotion continuum. Various incidents, people and places figure in the book as and when they are indispensable pieces of the jigsaw puzzle of the emotion that is being explored. But nothing is incongruous or disparate, all characters, all subplots and all subtexts come together harmoniously to create this wonderful story. Something completely distinctive (that perhaps makes this book a masterpiece) about Milan Kundera’s style of writing is that he defines characters not by how they look or what they wear, not even by what they say but by what they think and why they think and how they think. Finally the backdrop of the book is the chequered and tattered life of East European communist nations, but in this great book political theory plays second fiddle to the people and their emotions that get affected by politics, politics almost becomes personal.
Enough said, will complete the review with some of the gems that stayed back with me from the book. I don’t think you need a context to appreciate them but if you do then don’t forget to pick up the book.
“For there is nothing heavier than compassion “
“If mother was sacrifice personified then a daughter was Guilt with no possibility of redress”
“Of course I am happy.. The only kind of woman who can say that is very… limited. .. Not limited, very anachronistic.”
“But when the strong were too weak to hurt the weak, the weak have to be strong enough to leave.”
“Love was not an extension of public life but its antithesis.”
“Music was the negation of sentences, music was the anti word.”
“The first betrayal is irreparable. It calls forth a chain reaction of further betrayals, each of which takes us farther and farther away from our first betrayal.”
“Because love means renouncing strength”
“What fell to her lot was not the burden but the unbearable light ness of being.”
“Indeed, the only truly serious questions are the ones that even a child can formulate.”
“It is a tragicomic fact that our proper upbringing has become an ally of the secret police. We do not know how to lie”
“Human time does not run in a circle, it runs ahead in a straight line. That is why man cannot be happy, happiness is the longing for repetition”
Tuesday, June 29, 2010
Rabbit Run
As I read Rabbit Run by John Updike over the weekend, I was reminded of a similar week 13 years ago when I completed Gone With The Wind in 3 days straight. Like Rabbit Run, I picked up Gone With The Wind many times, only to be dissuaded by the details of the party Scarlet had to attend, once I got over the tedium of the first 50 pages there was no stopping me. Scarlet and her tale fascinated me at so many levels. Inadvertently Scarlet aroused empathy, intrigue and admiration. Her cry for “I shall never be hungry again” resonated strongly, the realization that the American nation had changed for ever at so many socio economic and political levels after the Civil War while searching for parallels closer home took me back to the book many many times. The similarity with Rabbit Run, once I got over the tedium of the first 40 pages where Rabbit plans and fails to run away from his family, the book gripped me and I finished in a day and half flat.
Rabbit Run is the first of the series by Pulitzer Prize winning author John Updike and often considered to be the best in the Rabbit series. The protagonist is Harry” Rabbit” Angstrom, the quintessential Peter Pan, married with a child and a semi responsible job, steadfastedly refusing to grow up. The backdrop of Rabbit’s struggle is the dark underbelly of small town America, often the tedium of life in the small town adding to Rabbit’s real or imaginary woes. The book covers 5 months in the life of Rabbit, his family and his mistress and is quite limited in its field of vision both in terms of time and the landscape. What makes the book a page turner is one the intrigue the author manages to create through crafty situations and perceptive dialogue, of what shall happen next to Rabbit and his life that he specializes in messing up. More importantly it is the insight with which the author captures the struggles of the quintessential modern day American Peter Pan. 26 year old Harry Angstrom refers to himself by his childhood nickname Rabbit, symbolic of his yearning to get back to the high school basketball court probably the only place he ever aced at. Rabbit is out of sorts in the grown up world, never quite knowing what he wanted his life to be but sure he hates what it is now. Updike through a collage of conversations, insights and reminisces explores the angst that Rabbit goes through trying to be a father, husband to alcoholic (and pregnant) Janice and responsible employee when all he would rather do is shoot hoops at the court, the angst that finally forces him to run out on his family and seek refuge in a hurried (but seemingly) happy affair. One such conversation is my aha moment in this book where Rabbit says, “When you have been best at something, being second best is just not good enough”. The world from Rabbit’s vantage point does seem unfair and the author manages to not make you hate Rabbit for his juvenile longings and irresponsible running away. You regale a bit as he enjoys the simple things that life has to offer with his new found mistress however the tables turn as soon as there are signs of distress and Rabbit confused again chooses the path of least resistance.
What John Updike manages to create through the mastery of his craft is a mélange of characters in Rabbit’s life who project a quality Rabbit himself does not possess.
So in his alcoholic wife Janice rabbit sees probably the personification of all the seven deadly sins, she is sloth, greed, lust and all the evil that emotionally stunted rabbit can perceive. He loves to hate her, so much so that when Janice puts her best foot forward to reform he pushes her to the same bad habits he hates her for. His coach Marty Jo manifests for him the desire to win which he once could and the desire to inspire which he knows he fails miserably at. His mistress Ruth in an obvious paradox is the prostitute who for him represents the good and pure life. The preacher is his voice of conscious, his connection to God, which for most part is absent, only surfacing to add to his already prolific confusions. Through the maze of all these people who pull him in different directions, Rabbit aimlessly wanders from crisis to crisis.
I enjoyed reading Rabbit Run, what works for the book is the insightful journey through small town America, the firm etching of characters through master strokes of conversations, reactions and incidents where not even a word seems wasteful. However having said that will I ever get back to it or will I ever attempt to read the sequels, I am not to sure about that. And that is why the book does not work for me completely. It fails to create empathy or sympathy for Rabbit. Rabbit does not evoke pity, interest or even sufficient anger. As the book ends you are just a trifle irritated with Rabbit and his juvenile search for the proverbial pot of gold at the end of the rainbow. And when his coach asks him “Does it even exist”. . you tend to agree.
Rabbit Run is the first of the series by Pulitzer Prize winning author John Updike and often considered to be the best in the Rabbit series. The protagonist is Harry” Rabbit” Angstrom, the quintessential Peter Pan, married with a child and a semi responsible job, steadfastedly refusing to grow up. The backdrop of Rabbit’s struggle is the dark underbelly of small town America, often the tedium of life in the small town adding to Rabbit’s real or imaginary woes. The book covers 5 months in the life of Rabbit, his family and his mistress and is quite limited in its field of vision both in terms of time and the landscape. What makes the book a page turner is one the intrigue the author manages to create through crafty situations and perceptive dialogue, of what shall happen next to Rabbit and his life that he specializes in messing up. More importantly it is the insight with which the author captures the struggles of the quintessential modern day American Peter Pan. 26 year old Harry Angstrom refers to himself by his childhood nickname Rabbit, symbolic of his yearning to get back to the high school basketball court probably the only place he ever aced at. Rabbit is out of sorts in the grown up world, never quite knowing what he wanted his life to be but sure he hates what it is now. Updike through a collage of conversations, insights and reminisces explores the angst that Rabbit goes through trying to be a father, husband to alcoholic (and pregnant) Janice and responsible employee when all he would rather do is shoot hoops at the court, the angst that finally forces him to run out on his family and seek refuge in a hurried (but seemingly) happy affair. One such conversation is my aha moment in this book where Rabbit says, “When you have been best at something, being second best is just not good enough”. The world from Rabbit’s vantage point does seem unfair and the author manages to not make you hate Rabbit for his juvenile longings and irresponsible running away. You regale a bit as he enjoys the simple things that life has to offer with his new found mistress however the tables turn as soon as there are signs of distress and Rabbit confused again chooses the path of least resistance.
What John Updike manages to create through the mastery of his craft is a mélange of characters in Rabbit’s life who project a quality Rabbit himself does not possess.
So in his alcoholic wife Janice rabbit sees probably the personification of all the seven deadly sins, she is sloth, greed, lust and all the evil that emotionally stunted rabbit can perceive. He loves to hate her, so much so that when Janice puts her best foot forward to reform he pushes her to the same bad habits he hates her for. His coach Marty Jo manifests for him the desire to win which he once could and the desire to inspire which he knows he fails miserably at. His mistress Ruth in an obvious paradox is the prostitute who for him represents the good and pure life. The preacher is his voice of conscious, his connection to God, which for most part is absent, only surfacing to add to his already prolific confusions. Through the maze of all these people who pull him in different directions, Rabbit aimlessly wanders from crisis to crisis.
I enjoyed reading Rabbit Run, what works for the book is the insightful journey through small town America, the firm etching of characters through master strokes of conversations, reactions and incidents where not even a word seems wasteful. However having said that will I ever get back to it or will I ever attempt to read the sequels, I am not to sure about that. And that is why the book does not work for me completely. It fails to create empathy or sympathy for Rabbit. Rabbit does not evoke pity, interest or even sufficient anger. As the book ends you are just a trifle irritated with Rabbit and his juvenile search for the proverbial pot of gold at the end of the rainbow. And when his coach asks him “Does it even exist”. . you tend to agree.
Sunday, May 30, 2010
Underground:The Tokyo Gas Attack and the Japanese Psyche
Well I am back after a month and a half hiatus, having lost the 3 readers of this blog in the process. Well why was I away, loads of work, no time to write and no time to read also. And also no peace of mind, no particular reason to be cranky and that made recovery even harder. Finally the clouds lifted last Sunday, nothing had changed except I decided to smile (of course the husband’s tickling helped). While I was not writing I was constantly thinking about this blog and should I even come back to it especially after I am so so behind. With peace of mind, skip in the step and song on my lips restored not coming back seemed like a moronic option. I mean who cares about how far behind I am on the challenge, I read a book and I shall inflict the review on the greater world.
So what’s the book : Underground by Haruki Marukami. Picked it up from Chennai airport, the book is about the 1995 Tokyo Gas Attack and the affect it had on the nation’s psyche. The book originally written in Japanese is a compilation of interviews of survivors of the tragedy and family of the victims. The author sites putting a face to victims rather than hide the pain behind figures as the reason of wanting to write the book. Also the long lasting effect that the tragedy has had on people who were ill fated to be on that train that Monday morning.
The book is not lyrical in its style of writing. The beauty of the book does not lie in its beautiful prose but in the way it brings together the truth of many lives, both the victims and the perpetuators of the violent act. It is journalistic in the way it presents points of view and facts without interpretation and judgment. It allows the reader to absorb and interpret the tragedy and its manifestations without being weighed down by the judgment of the author. The first part has many accounts of the victims, each different in the extent of damage and method of coping with it. What stays behind and totally flips your view of such disasters is that its quantum cannot be measured by the number of lives lost (13 people died that day), even one death is one too many. The heartbreaking story of the expecting widow or the dutiful brother stays behind even as you finish the book. For me it was also a sneak peak into the Japanese people and their way of life. Their commitment to work was evident in the number of people reporting back to work despite signs of discomfort (arguably increasing the damage caused by Sarin), also the number of hours people work and the general sense of propriety towards work was well almost intriguing. As in the case of individuals’, a people’s reaction to a tragedy is a true reflection of its personality and in this case everyone reacted methodically with calm, without hysteria. People seemed to act more out of duty not empathy, the reactions specially as in the accounts recorded nearly 2 years after the tragedy were so measured and to my melodramatic Indian soul almost cold. The hatred however, towards the perpetuators of the crime, the Aum Shrinkyo is unequivocal and intense.
The fear of the unknown haunts these victims, the simplicity of the crime and the extent of damage it caused (measured by the thousands of people who complain of headache, nausea, loss of sight etc etc) and the potential damage is infact chilling. Though the world has moved on since 1995 and in these 15 years terrorism is in everyone’s backyard, the fact that a few demented minds can wreck so many lives without any effort still manages to shock me. Finally what clearly runs as a common theme through all these accounts is the “Us vs. Them”, most victims and indeed Japanese post the attacj refused to recognize the members of the Aum cult as part of their very own society. Even with no demographic, socio economic or linguistic definitions separating the Aum members from the rest of the society no one acknowledged that they were infact part of the same social fabric. Imagine how hard it is to share the burden of the crime when nationalities, religions and languages create a barrier.
And this brings me to the second part of the book, titled appropriately “The Place That was Promised”. With this part, the book completes itself making it a must read for having presented both sides of the coin in the most unbiased way it is possible. This is a collection of the interviews of members from the Aum. Marukami delivers on the job when he presents the human side of people you hate in the first part. Most interviewees have lives similar to that of the victims, they could have been neighbours for all you know. What sets them apart is their uni-dimensional pursuit of what they think is the “Truth”, their inability to fit into society and their supreme faith in the logic of their beliefs. Their loneliness forcing them to seek solace in the “guru’s” wisdom, wisdom that slowly takes away all their sense of reality. There is no room for grey in their minds and anyone who does not comply with their school of thought is wrong. A thread that runs so commonly across all right wing and left wing terrorists. It is when you do not allow a little room for a little doubt that being inhumane does not seem wrong. All Aum followers were by products of the same society that they sought to destroy. Harukami establishes his craft, while interviewing the Aum followers, probing a little deeper, forcing them to share insights far bigger than they initially intended to. The second part of the book is an addendum, but a befitting one that completes the book for me. You end up hating the perpetrators of the crime in the first part but at the end of the second one you are not so sure.
The criminals are nothing but victims themselves.
So what’s the book : Underground by Haruki Marukami. Picked it up from Chennai airport, the book is about the 1995 Tokyo Gas Attack and the affect it had on the nation’s psyche. The book originally written in Japanese is a compilation of interviews of survivors of the tragedy and family of the victims. The author sites putting a face to victims rather than hide the pain behind figures as the reason of wanting to write the book. Also the long lasting effect that the tragedy has had on people who were ill fated to be on that train that Monday morning.
The book is not lyrical in its style of writing. The beauty of the book does not lie in its beautiful prose but in the way it brings together the truth of many lives, both the victims and the perpetuators of the violent act. It is journalistic in the way it presents points of view and facts without interpretation and judgment. It allows the reader to absorb and interpret the tragedy and its manifestations without being weighed down by the judgment of the author. The first part has many accounts of the victims, each different in the extent of damage and method of coping with it. What stays behind and totally flips your view of such disasters is that its quantum cannot be measured by the number of lives lost (13 people died that day), even one death is one too many. The heartbreaking story of the expecting widow or the dutiful brother stays behind even as you finish the book. For me it was also a sneak peak into the Japanese people and their way of life. Their commitment to work was evident in the number of people reporting back to work despite signs of discomfort (arguably increasing the damage caused by Sarin), also the number of hours people work and the general sense of propriety towards work was well almost intriguing. As in the case of individuals’, a people’s reaction to a tragedy is a true reflection of its personality and in this case everyone reacted methodically with calm, without hysteria. People seemed to act more out of duty not empathy, the reactions specially as in the accounts recorded nearly 2 years after the tragedy were so measured and to my melodramatic Indian soul almost cold. The hatred however, towards the perpetuators of the crime, the Aum Shrinkyo is unequivocal and intense.
The fear of the unknown haunts these victims, the simplicity of the crime and the extent of damage it caused (measured by the thousands of people who complain of headache, nausea, loss of sight etc etc) and the potential damage is infact chilling. Though the world has moved on since 1995 and in these 15 years terrorism is in everyone’s backyard, the fact that a few demented minds can wreck so many lives without any effort still manages to shock me. Finally what clearly runs as a common theme through all these accounts is the “Us vs. Them”, most victims and indeed Japanese post the attacj refused to recognize the members of the Aum cult as part of their very own society. Even with no demographic, socio economic or linguistic definitions separating the Aum members from the rest of the society no one acknowledged that they were infact part of the same social fabric. Imagine how hard it is to share the burden of the crime when nationalities, religions and languages create a barrier.
And this brings me to the second part of the book, titled appropriately “The Place That was Promised”. With this part, the book completes itself making it a must read for having presented both sides of the coin in the most unbiased way it is possible. This is a collection of the interviews of members from the Aum. Marukami delivers on the job when he presents the human side of people you hate in the first part. Most interviewees have lives similar to that of the victims, they could have been neighbours for all you know. What sets them apart is their uni-dimensional pursuit of what they think is the “Truth”, their inability to fit into society and their supreme faith in the logic of their beliefs. Their loneliness forcing them to seek solace in the “guru’s” wisdom, wisdom that slowly takes away all their sense of reality. There is no room for grey in their minds and anyone who does not comply with their school of thought is wrong. A thread that runs so commonly across all right wing and left wing terrorists. It is when you do not allow a little room for a little doubt that being inhumane does not seem wrong. All Aum followers were by products of the same society that they sought to destroy. Harukami establishes his craft, while interviewing the Aum followers, probing a little deeper, forcing them to share insights far bigger than they initially intended to. The second part of the book is an addendum, but a befitting one that completes the book for me. You end up hating the perpetrators of the crime in the first part but at the end of the second one you are not so sure.
The criminals are nothing but victims themselves.
Sunday, April 11, 2010
Focus: Arthur Miller
I should not have waited for so long to write this review. I read the book almost a month back and kept postponing the review writing till I had something spectacular to say. I was busy and that added to the procrastination.
But here I am a month later falling terribly behind the goal of 1 book a week and still struggling with what to write.
It is safe to say that the book did not evoke extraordinary reactions from me. The book is not mediocre however my reactions to it are moderate, which cannot be coincidental given that the book deals with extremism and moderation. The book set in 1940s New York is almost a biographical account of Anti-Semitism from the great playwright Arthur Miller.
The protagonist of the book is Newman, a middle class American in his early 40s working in New York during the Second World War. Miller does an excellent job is creating the character of Newman as the quintessential middle class average bloke who well quire literally treads the middle path. Like a middle class person anywhere in the world at any given point of time, he is very sure of his moralities. He is neither the perpetuator of wrong neither is he is the savior of the destitute. He lives his life reassured of his indispensability to society and is not too perturbed by the evident lack of extraordinary progress in his career. Since the book is about social and cultural; prejudices, Newman’s social interactions are pivotal in understanding his character and the changes that will happen in due course of time. Newman maintains a respectable distance from most people, completely comfortable in the skin that he is in. As a white collar Christian worker he does not need anyone to ratify him, he goes about life stereotyping people and cultures, interacting with them through the mirror of those stereotypes.
This is what I definitely like about the book, it has a timeless appeal, the people and their insecurities, reactions and quirks did not seem dated to me. I know that somewhere in the backyard of America/India a character like Newman still exists. The grounds of discrimination also remain the same: “The Kikes will take away our jobs.
A twist of fate and a pair of spectacles later, Newman is forced to face life looking like a Jew. Though seemingly incredulous Miller builds this element in the story quite effortlessly and soon as the reader accompanies Newman on his travails as a Jew she forgets that is the spectacle that makes Newman look Jewish.
The fact that Newman is now looking like a Jew, turns his life (and his garbage can) upside down. From a detached fence sitter on the sidelines of the rising Anti Semitic sentiment, Newman is forcefully thrown into the middle of it. The transformation of Newman from a confident, assured and sometimes even politely brash citizen of the city to a tentative, apologetic and self conscious man, who is hoping to squash fewer toes than his mere presence does, is what to me the AHA moment of the book is. Miller superbly captures the confusion of Newman as he goes about recalibrating life as a Jew. His takes his loses in his stride and tries the supreme “middle class tactic” of staying out of trouble. You feel sorry for Newman as he tries his best to fit in, as he valiantly tries to prove he is not Jew, he ensures he has nothing to do with the other Jew on the street and much to his dislike even tries to be part of the Anti Semitic hooliganism. The book chronicles his journey till he finds peace with his new found existence.
The book is insightful as it captures the nuances of discrimination well; anyone who has been on the other side of the bargain is quick to notice the subtle but strong signals that
”normal people “give. I can say this with some experience for at least I have always felt discriminated against as a person who struggled with her weight for most of her life! Real or imagined, the fact that I thought I was not normal specially during my teenage years was enough for me to be super sensitive to what people said, or how they stared sometimes even blaming myself for the eve teasing that is a way of life for young girls in small town UP. You do what it takes to be normal and that’s what Newman did.
The book is to my mind is Arthur Miller’s attempt of making sense of the madness around him. He uses this incredulous situation of a normal Christian American suddenly transforming into a Jew overnight to steer his path on how to deal with the madness of it all. It is simplistic in how it seeks a solution to the ever increasing hate and its ramifications. Maybe this is the reason why the book fails to create the kind of impact I expected it to, it is too simplistic, insightful but ended as Arthur Miller finds the truth for himself.
What works for this book is its timelessness, most evident in the passage where Newman puts the face of Finkelstein his neighbor, on all the vices that Jews supposedly have. He struggles to find Finkelstein guilty of even one of them and yet is unable to let go off his own prejudices. The people and places have changed, yet the fact that the Muslim the world over, the Indian in Australia, the North Eastern student in Delhi, the North Indian in Mumbai all struggle to defend themselves individually against crimes they have committed collectively as a culture.
Will I recommend it, it is moderate in the impact it creates but yes it is a piece that will probably help in understanding that prejudice is not new hopefully how we will deal with it can be.
But here I am a month later falling terribly behind the goal of 1 book a week and still struggling with what to write.
It is safe to say that the book did not evoke extraordinary reactions from me. The book is not mediocre however my reactions to it are moderate, which cannot be coincidental given that the book deals with extremism and moderation. The book set in 1940s New York is almost a biographical account of Anti-Semitism from the great playwright Arthur Miller.
The protagonist of the book is Newman, a middle class American in his early 40s working in New York during the Second World War. Miller does an excellent job is creating the character of Newman as the quintessential middle class average bloke who well quire literally treads the middle path. Like a middle class person anywhere in the world at any given point of time, he is very sure of his moralities. He is neither the perpetuator of wrong neither is he is the savior of the destitute. He lives his life reassured of his indispensability to society and is not too perturbed by the evident lack of extraordinary progress in his career. Since the book is about social and cultural; prejudices, Newman’s social interactions are pivotal in understanding his character and the changes that will happen in due course of time. Newman maintains a respectable distance from most people, completely comfortable in the skin that he is in. As a white collar Christian worker he does not need anyone to ratify him, he goes about life stereotyping people and cultures, interacting with them through the mirror of those stereotypes.
This is what I definitely like about the book, it has a timeless appeal, the people and their insecurities, reactions and quirks did not seem dated to me. I know that somewhere in the backyard of America/India a character like Newman still exists. The grounds of discrimination also remain the same: “The Kikes will take away our jobs.
A twist of fate and a pair of spectacles later, Newman is forced to face life looking like a Jew. Though seemingly incredulous Miller builds this element in the story quite effortlessly and soon as the reader accompanies Newman on his travails as a Jew she forgets that is the spectacle that makes Newman look Jewish.
The fact that Newman is now looking like a Jew, turns his life (and his garbage can) upside down. From a detached fence sitter on the sidelines of the rising Anti Semitic sentiment, Newman is forcefully thrown into the middle of it. The transformation of Newman from a confident, assured and sometimes even politely brash citizen of the city to a tentative, apologetic and self conscious man, who is hoping to squash fewer toes than his mere presence does, is what to me the AHA moment of the book is. Miller superbly captures the confusion of Newman as he goes about recalibrating life as a Jew. His takes his loses in his stride and tries the supreme “middle class tactic” of staying out of trouble. You feel sorry for Newman as he tries his best to fit in, as he valiantly tries to prove he is not Jew, he ensures he has nothing to do with the other Jew on the street and much to his dislike even tries to be part of the Anti Semitic hooliganism. The book chronicles his journey till he finds peace with his new found existence.
The book is insightful as it captures the nuances of discrimination well; anyone who has been on the other side of the bargain is quick to notice the subtle but strong signals that
”normal people “give. I can say this with some experience for at least I have always felt discriminated against as a person who struggled with her weight for most of her life! Real or imagined, the fact that I thought I was not normal specially during my teenage years was enough for me to be super sensitive to what people said, or how they stared sometimes even blaming myself for the eve teasing that is a way of life for young girls in small town UP. You do what it takes to be normal and that’s what Newman did.
The book is to my mind is Arthur Miller’s attempt of making sense of the madness around him. He uses this incredulous situation of a normal Christian American suddenly transforming into a Jew overnight to steer his path on how to deal with the madness of it all. It is simplistic in how it seeks a solution to the ever increasing hate and its ramifications. Maybe this is the reason why the book fails to create the kind of impact I expected it to, it is too simplistic, insightful but ended as Arthur Miller finds the truth for himself.
What works for this book is its timelessness, most evident in the passage where Newman puts the face of Finkelstein his neighbor, on all the vices that Jews supposedly have. He struggles to find Finkelstein guilty of even one of them and yet is unable to let go off his own prejudices. The people and places have changed, yet the fact that the Muslim the world over, the Indian in Australia, the North Eastern student in Delhi, the North Indian in Mumbai all struggle to defend themselves individually against crimes they have committed collectively as a culture.
Will I recommend it, it is moderate in the impact it creates but yes it is a piece that will probably help in understanding that prejudice is not new hopefully how we will deal with it can be.
Monday, March 15, 2010
Three Cups of Tea: A Review
Well I get delirious in a book shop and like many who cant get out of a shoe shop without a shoe, I can’t get out of a book shop without a book. Often even without being in a hurry, I pick up books like the chocolate deprived child who has gained access to Charlie’s Magical Chocolate Factory, in a hurry never knowing when the alarm bell will go off putting an end to the escapade a little too soon. Often in this hurry I pick up books I can never read, books which are well boring.
I entered the Chennai Airport Book Store and hoped that I would find something read worthy (airport book stores are normally hopeless). I looked and looked and found an interesting title “Three Cups of Tea:, my friends will know I can never go past a book titled that. Picked it up and was intrigued enough by the jacket description. A book about a climber who goes back to the villages at the base of K2 to build schools. In a super exited state I picked that up along with Haruki Marukami (hopefully will review that by Tuesday!)
Anyway I got onto the plane, abandoned Darkness at Noon (what is with that book and me.. cant seem to get beyond the 100th page each time I pick it up). As I relaxed and began leafing through the book, an important detail caught my eye. This edition was the “Young Reader’s” edition. With my other books packed away in the luggage rack, I reckoned (was dying to use that word for some reason) no harm will be done if I read a few pages of this book.
And so I started a little curious, a little doubtful. But I was captivated. Goes to prove a good story, an inspiring hero and an honest account maybe meant for anyone but is loved by all. The story is about Greg Mortenson who vows to climb Mount K2 as a tribute to his sister Christa. He gets lost on his way up and ends up in the small small village of Korphe. The simple villagers and their chief Haji Ali take him in as an esteemed guest and play host to him with the best of their very limited resources. Moved by their hospitality and the fact that the young children had only an empty field and a teacher 3 days a week for a school. He saw the children diligently practice their multiplication tables in the dirt without a teacher and vowed to build a school for them. Many of us go through moments in life where a cause greater than us inspires us and most of us return back to our real worlds cherishing the memories of that inspiration but little else. What makes this story heroic is that he actually came back to build the school. Greg Mortenson was not one of your quintessential rich American boys who had a stash of cash piled away at home. He came back, was unemployed, homeless and wrote 250 letters to celebrities trying to enlist their support, nothing came around. He persevered and finally got the money to build the school, reached Khorpe only to discover he had to build a bridge first.
The book then takes the reader through the remarkable journey of Greg’s first school and then many more through the establishment of the Central Asian Institute. The tough terrain, lack of resources and even a kidnapping could not break Greg’s spirit as he trudged through North West Pakistan building schools for little girls and boys.
Greg endears himself to the local population and it is with their support, their land and their hard work he builds schools. He forms lasting friendships with the people often learning more from them than he could ever hope to teach.
In the end this book though meant for children left me feeling inspired and awed and recharged, a feat many books aimed for people my age fail to do. What makes this book special is the fact it makes an attempt to acquaint children with the reality of what is happening in the world. Often I read how parents are torn between exposing their kids to the cruel reality too soon and keeping their children protected too long. I think this book is the perfect medium to introduce children to the reality of war, refugee camps and unschooled children as it does not fill them with despair but equips them with hope and a tool to help. The book introduces the “Pennies for Peace” program run in schools across the US. On a completely unrelated note I know two very special girls who collected their pocket money to make stationary sets for children who need them. I hope this book will make more such kids come forward.
My two aha moments in this book, Greg is in the middle of a school opening in Pakistan when 9/11 happens. The old village chief on learning this gave an honest speech; he knew that terrorism is not because of evil but mostly because of poverty and no education. Greg after the speech says “I think all who think “muslim” is another way of saying terrorist could have been there that day. The core tenets of Islam are justice, tolerance and charity”. I wish we all could just open ourselves a little and get to know people before we label them.
The second one came pretty early on in the book, as Greg saw the children study on the frosty ground he wondered “Can you imagine a fourth grade class in America, alone, without a teacher sitting there quietly working on their lessons?” I know what he feels; I have seen too many bratty and whiny 8 year olds. Whatever little time I have spent with underprivileged kids I am yet to see anyone of them complain. Compare that to your average 8 year old.
Actually there was another aha moment in the book, Jahan a young girl says “ I could not take my eyes off the foreign ladies, they seemed so dignified…… one day Allah willing I shall be a great lady too”. It reminded me of what education means to a lot of people.
I will pick up the grown up version of the book very soon, and if you have a young reader at home I have a spare copy. This is one book I would not mind lending.
I entered the Chennai Airport Book Store and hoped that I would find something read worthy (airport book stores are normally hopeless). I looked and looked and found an interesting title “Three Cups of Tea:, my friends will know I can never go past a book titled that. Picked it up and was intrigued enough by the jacket description. A book about a climber who goes back to the villages at the base of K2 to build schools. In a super exited state I picked that up along with Haruki Marukami (hopefully will review that by Tuesday!)
Anyway I got onto the plane, abandoned Darkness at Noon (what is with that book and me.. cant seem to get beyond the 100th page each time I pick it up). As I relaxed and began leafing through the book, an important detail caught my eye. This edition was the “Young Reader’s” edition. With my other books packed away in the luggage rack, I reckoned (was dying to use that word for some reason) no harm will be done if I read a few pages of this book.
And so I started a little curious, a little doubtful. But I was captivated. Goes to prove a good story, an inspiring hero and an honest account maybe meant for anyone but is loved by all. The story is about Greg Mortenson who vows to climb Mount K2 as a tribute to his sister Christa. He gets lost on his way up and ends up in the small small village of Korphe. The simple villagers and their chief Haji Ali take him in as an esteemed guest and play host to him with the best of their very limited resources. Moved by their hospitality and the fact that the young children had only an empty field and a teacher 3 days a week for a school. He saw the children diligently practice their multiplication tables in the dirt without a teacher and vowed to build a school for them. Many of us go through moments in life where a cause greater than us inspires us and most of us return back to our real worlds cherishing the memories of that inspiration but little else. What makes this story heroic is that he actually came back to build the school. Greg Mortenson was not one of your quintessential rich American boys who had a stash of cash piled away at home. He came back, was unemployed, homeless and wrote 250 letters to celebrities trying to enlist their support, nothing came around. He persevered and finally got the money to build the school, reached Khorpe only to discover he had to build a bridge first.
The book then takes the reader through the remarkable journey of Greg’s first school and then many more through the establishment of the Central Asian Institute. The tough terrain, lack of resources and even a kidnapping could not break Greg’s spirit as he trudged through North West Pakistan building schools for little girls and boys.
Greg endears himself to the local population and it is with their support, their land and their hard work he builds schools. He forms lasting friendships with the people often learning more from them than he could ever hope to teach.
In the end this book though meant for children left me feeling inspired and awed and recharged, a feat many books aimed for people my age fail to do. What makes this book special is the fact it makes an attempt to acquaint children with the reality of what is happening in the world. Often I read how parents are torn between exposing their kids to the cruel reality too soon and keeping their children protected too long. I think this book is the perfect medium to introduce children to the reality of war, refugee camps and unschooled children as it does not fill them with despair but equips them with hope and a tool to help. The book introduces the “Pennies for Peace” program run in schools across the US. On a completely unrelated note I know two very special girls who collected their pocket money to make stationary sets for children who need them. I hope this book will make more such kids come forward.
My two aha moments in this book, Greg is in the middle of a school opening in Pakistan when 9/11 happens. The old village chief on learning this gave an honest speech; he knew that terrorism is not because of evil but mostly because of poverty and no education. Greg after the speech says “I think all who think “muslim” is another way of saying terrorist could have been there that day. The core tenets of Islam are justice, tolerance and charity”. I wish we all could just open ourselves a little and get to know people before we label them.
The second one came pretty early on in the book, as Greg saw the children study on the frosty ground he wondered “Can you imagine a fourth grade class in America, alone, without a teacher sitting there quietly working on their lessons?” I know what he feels; I have seen too many bratty and whiny 8 year olds. Whatever little time I have spent with underprivileged kids I am yet to see anyone of them complain. Compare that to your average 8 year old.
Actually there was another aha moment in the book, Jahan a young girl says “ I could not take my eyes off the foreign ladies, they seemed so dignified…… one day Allah willing I shall be a great lady too”. It reminded me of what education means to a lot of people.
I will pick up the grown up version of the book very soon, and if you have a young reader at home I have a spare copy. This is one book I would not mind lending.
Saturday, February 6, 2010
Summer Crossing: A Review
As I review Summer Crossing, I realise that this review cannot be a critique as much as it needs to be an appreciation of the evolution of the genius of Truman Capote. The fact that this was the debut novel of Capote was more than enough for me to pick this book up during my ten minute book buying spree at Blossoms a couple of months back. What made it even more interesting was the fact that the book was published by Truman's friends after his death post an accidental discovery of the unedited manuscript. I read the afterword to the novel before I read the story. The afterword makes it clear that publishing this novel was perhaps not Truman's wish as much as it was his friends desire.
I fell in love with Capote's work with Breakfast at Tiffanys and even as I read the first few pages of Summer Crossing I knew that this one was no where close to it in technique. The depth of insight and brevity of expression that endeared BAT was totally amiss in SC. The technique may be awry but there are traces of a brilliant story line. The novel written in the 1940s still finds a place with its universal theme of teenage angst and first love.
At the centre of the book is Grady, a stereotypical poor little rich girl. The daughter of wealthy New York parents, she is a rebel without a cause or a pause like teenagers are wont to be. Absorbed in her own world, for an inexplicable reason Grady resents her parents and the world they represent. The fact that Clyde is the antithesis of her parents is what seems to attract Grady to him. What follows is a somewhat predictable struggle of the heart vs. the head, compounded by the fact that neither Grady nor Clyde seem to know what is it about the other that makes the struggle worth it. The book uses New York and its diversity as a backdrop and at times the narrative becomes tedious with descriptors. However what could have potentially made this a novella worth its salt is how Capote captures the dilemma of a teenager caught between two worlds, two sensibilities and two completely opposite desires. Grady hopes for adventure as much as she yearns for the staid, she appreciates the sophistication of her friends and is infatuated by the raw Bronx. What touches the heart however is the depiction of isolation of a teenager, the loneliness that eats into a teenager's soul, childish to adults but intense for her. The despair and helplessness that Grady feels about the mess she seems to have got herself into is made worse by the impermeable cocoon she builds around herself, where even her partner in crime cannot be her confidante .
Will I recommend the book maybe yes for a quick read, definitely maybe for a Capote fan to understand his evolution as a writer.
Finally for my aha moment, there were two. The first one when the narrative shifts from Grady's vantage point to Clyde's. Till that point Clyde was a gold digging buffoon ridiculed by all but adored by Grady. As the narrative shifts gears Clyde emerges as a confused young man struggling between aspiration, expectations and reality.This crafty twist was an aha moment. The second is this line "....for the P-somethings, made innocent by the world's goodwill, could not feel a shadow. As always go figure.
I fell in love with Capote's work with Breakfast at Tiffanys and even as I read the first few pages of Summer Crossing I knew that this one was no where close to it in technique. The depth of insight and brevity of expression that endeared BAT was totally amiss in SC. The technique may be awry but there are traces of a brilliant story line. The novel written in the 1940s still finds a place with its universal theme of teenage angst and first love.
At the centre of the book is Grady, a stereotypical poor little rich girl. The daughter of wealthy New York parents, she is a rebel without a cause or a pause like teenagers are wont to be. Absorbed in her own world, for an inexplicable reason Grady resents her parents and the world they represent. The fact that Clyde is the antithesis of her parents is what seems to attract Grady to him. What follows is a somewhat predictable struggle of the heart vs. the head, compounded by the fact that neither Grady nor Clyde seem to know what is it about the other that makes the struggle worth it. The book uses New York and its diversity as a backdrop and at times the narrative becomes tedious with descriptors. However what could have potentially made this a novella worth its salt is how Capote captures the dilemma of a teenager caught between two worlds, two sensibilities and two completely opposite desires. Grady hopes for adventure as much as she yearns for the staid, she appreciates the sophistication of her friends and is infatuated by the raw Bronx. What touches the heart however is the depiction of isolation of a teenager, the loneliness that eats into a teenager's soul, childish to adults but intense for her. The despair and helplessness that Grady feels about the mess she seems to have got herself into is made worse by the impermeable cocoon she builds around herself, where even her partner in crime cannot be her confidante .
Will I recommend the book maybe yes for a quick read, definitely maybe for a Capote fan to understand his evolution as a writer.
Finally for my aha moment, there were two. The first one when the narrative shifts from Grady's vantage point to Clyde's. Till that point Clyde was a gold digging buffoon ridiculed by all but adored by Grady. As the narrative shifts gears Clyde emerges as a confused young man struggling between aspiration, expectations and reality.This crafty twist was an aha moment. The second is this line "....for the P-somethings, made innocent by the world's goodwill, could not feel a shadow. As always go figure.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)